Reddit: Draft Analysts Advise Patience with Bryce Young, Former Alabama Heisman-Winning QB, in the NFL
Originally posted on A to Z Sports by Rob Gregson | Last updated 5/28/24
Despite a challenging rookie NFL season, former Alabama QB Bryce Young, who won the Heisman Trophy, has been prematurely dismissed by many in the media. Some critics have labeled him a bust, citing his first-year performance as evidence of his limitations. However, a closer examination suggests reasons for optimism despite Young’s struggles.
**Destin Adams’ Assessment: C-**
Destin Adams of A to Z Sports Indianapolis and NFL Draft acknowledges the tough decisions made by the Carolina Panthers, including choosing Bryce Young over C.J. Stroud and trading significant assets to acquire Young. Adams gives Young a C- for his rookie year, recognizing the challenges and the high expectations set by the Panthers’ investment.
**James Foster’s Assessment: D**
James Foster of A to Z Sports Film Room grades Young’s rookie season as a D. He notes the disappointment when comparing Young to C.J. Stroud, who is projected to be an elite quarterback. Foster points out Young’s limitations in arm talent but also acknowledges the poor support from his offensive line and receivers. Despite these issues, Foster believes there is still hope for Young’s future development.
**Future Outlook**
Adams highlights the potential positive impact of Dave Canales, the Panthers’ new head coach, who previously maximized Baker Mayfield’s performance as offensive coordinator in Tampa. While not a direct comparison, both Mayfield and Young share some physical similarities. Adams is eager to see how Canales will work with Young.
Young’s rookie season exposed flaws that were already known from his college days—his size and less-than-electric arm. However, his accuracy, decision-making, and football intelligence remain intact. The deficiencies in his offensive line protection and receiver separation only magnified these issues. With the addition of veteran receiver Diontae Johnson and explosive rookie Xavier Legette, there is hope that Young can prove his critics wrong, potentially as early as October.
